2:42 is Pure Pop Perfection
According to Joshua Allen, the "perfect pop song" is two minutes and forty two seconds long. And he uses one of my all time favorite songs, one I consider a serious contender for Perfect Pop Song, "There She Goes" by the La's. I loved the line about the song:
When “There She Goes” is over, I guarantee absolutely no one in the room goes: “Jesus, finally.”
So I checked my ripped collection in Amarok to see what I had. Given some small variation in ripping (my "There She Goes" clocked in at 2:43), I searched in my Collection tab of Amarok using "length:>160 length:<164" for the search terms, and I came up with:
Three of my favorite songs from the 4 CD "Children of Nuggets":
One of my favorite Cure songs:
An excellent Gram Parsons song, covered by Sheryl Crow and Emmylou Harris:
All in all, a filter that turns out pretty well, I'd say.
Comments
work there, trifle. Your amarok search seems to be testing
whether your 2:42(ish) songs are good, not whether your good
songs are 2:42ish. I guess you'd really have to be ranking all
the songs in your collection, so you could see the lengths of
the highly ranked ones, and who has time for that?
When I think of songs less than 3 minutes, I tend to think of
old songs from the 60s, the kind that you can fit so many of
on an oldies collection.
BTW I did your search on my collection and it turned up mostly
good stuff too... including Harry MacDonough's "Tessie" from
1903 :)
mm